Skip to content

Accessibility preferences

Text size:



Line spacing:




Change font:



Enhance inputs areas:
Crip the Law
  • About
    • Leadership
    • Contact
  • Our Work
    • Resources
    • Systemic Advocacy
    • Mentorship Program
    • Events
    • Our Services
  • Join
  • Merch
  • Blog and News
  • Donate
  • Volunteer

MDisBa & Crip the Law’s Comment Regarding the Alternative Pathways Implementation, Court File No. ADM10-8008

Posted on October 12, 2026 by Marissa Ditkowsky.

Author

  • Marissa Ditkowsky
    Marissa Ditkowsky

October 9, 2026

VIA ELECTRONIC FILING

Christa Rutherford-Block
Clerk of the Appellate Courts
305 Minnesota Judicial Center
25 Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Blvd.
St. Paul, MN 55155

Re: MDisBa & Crip the Law’s Comment Regarding the Alternative Pathways Implementation, Court File No. ADM10-8008

To the Honorable Justices of the Minnesota Supreme Court:

The Minnesota Disability Bar Association (“MDisBA”) and Crip the Law submit this comment in strong support of the proposed Curricular Pathway to attorney licensure.

MDisBA is an organization of Minnesota legal professionals including attorneys, judges, staff, and students with disabilities as well as nondisabled allies. Founded in 2022, MDisBA’s mission includes educating the community about legal professionals with disabilities and promoting access and eliminating barriers to the legal profession for people with disabilities. MDisBA has a vested interest in supporting alternative pathways to licensure that would improve access to the legal profession in Minnesota for people with disabilities.

The National Disabled Legal Professionals Association (NDLPA) d/b/a Crip the Law is a national association of disabled lawyers, judges, policy experts, legislators, academics, and other legal workers, professionals, and organizers. Crip the Law was founded in 2022 to organize and unify disabled legal professionals into a force for change, and to advocate for and empower disabled legal professionals. Crip the Law has a vested interest in ensuring multiple pathways to licensure that better reflect the needs of disabled and multiply-marginalized test takers and the value that they bring to the profession.

The proposed Curricular Pathway will help improve equitable access to the bar for aspiring attorneys with disabilities. Despite the fact that more than 28 percent of adult Americans identify as having a disability,1 only 5percent of employed lawyers, judges, magistrates, and other judicial workers identified as having a disability as of 2023.2 As of 2025, lawyers with disabilities represent approximately 2.13 percent of partners and only 3.06percent of all lawyers at law firms.3 While this percentage has increased over the past several years, the reported figures remain disproportionately low and are likely underreported.4

For many people with disabilities, the traditional bar exam presents significant barriers that have little to do with actual competence. High-stakes standardized testing such as the bar exam “reinforces outdated thinking of what intelligence, achievement, and competence mean” and is “rife with ableist assumptions.”5 In addition to the sheer cost of taking and preparing for the exam (which in and of itself disproportionately impacts disabled people, who are more likely to experience poverty6), disabled test takers face extensive barriers to accessing accommodations. Obtaining testing accommodations is often costly, time-consuming, and unpredictable, requiring extensive medical documentation and navigating an opaque approval process. Many disabled candidates are subject to arduous and invasive accommodation application procedures that often take several months to complete,and may require expensive evaluations by professionals who do not accept insurance. Bar exam accommodation procedures are difficult to navigate and significantly more demanding on the applicant than similar processes by peer institutions like law schools, colleges, and other standardized testing organizations.

Even when accommodations are granted, they do not always fully address an applicant’s needs. Accommodations can help mitigate some of the barriers disabled test takers face, but they cannot overcome the fundamental limitations of an examination that primarily measures speed, memorization, and endurance ratherthan practical lawyering ability or analytical skill. As a result, the structure of the bar exam itself candisproportionately disadvantage applicants with disabilities. This occurs against a broader backdrop in which disabled law students and attorneys encounter persistent social, physical, and institutional barriers throughout their educational and professional careers. These obstacles not only limit opportunities for individuals but also deprive the legal profession of talented and dedicated advocates. When combined with the high-stakes, single-sitting nature of the bar exam, these barriers create significant and often inequitable challenges for people with disabilities.

The Curricular Pathway offers a fair and rigorous alternative that will help to ensure competency whileremoving some of the obstacles to licensure for people with disabilities. By assessing competence through supervised practice, written work, client interactions, and ethical reflection, the pathway evaluates the skills lawyers truly use in practice. It allows students and aspiring lawyers with disabilities to demonstrate competence in environments where accommodations are already integrated into law school or employer processes, reducing both financial and administrative burdens.

Currently, the American Bar Association only requires that students take a minimum of 6 credits inexperiential learning.7 With law school curricula and the bar exam focused heavily on theory as opposed to actualpractice, many law students do not graduate with core skills required for competent practice.8 This pathway willnot only remove unnecessary barriers for licensure candidates with disabilities, but strengthen legal education itself by ensuring future attorneys enter the profession better prepared to serve clients and meet the demands of legal practice. Importantly, the Curricular Pathway preserves rigorous standards for licensure. Through structured portfolio review, anonymous assessment, and comprehensive rubrics, it promotes consistency, objectivity, and accountability while ensuring that candidates demonstrate the competencies essential to practice.

While we recommend providing a supervised practice pathway, we believe it is critical to offer a Curricular Pathway as an alternative. Pursuing a supervised practice pathway may limit or defer more competitive salaries, employment stability, and professional opportunities for some candidates. These limits may also disproportionately affect disabled applicants. For example, disabled workers may rely far more on employer-based health care plans, which may not be a given for temporary employment. As another example, a 2020 National Disability Institute (NDI) report estimated that households with a disabled adult require about 28 percent more income (or $17,690 per year for a household at the median income level) to achieve the same standard of living as households without a disabled adult.9 Waiting longer to access a competitive salary can therefore be devastating for some disabled applicants.

Research shows that bar examinations disproportionately disadvantage people of color,9 first-generation law students,10 and those from lower-income backgrounds—largely due to structural inequities in standardized testing and the high cost of commercial bar preparation.11 Grounding licensure in demonstrated legal skills and practical competencies, rather than performance on a single exam, advances a more fair and equitable system not only for candidates with disabilities, but for other marginalized communities as well.

For these reasons, MDisBA and Crip the Law urge adoption of the proposed pilot program. The CurricularPathway will expand access to the profession, enhance equity, and better reflect the realities of modern legal practice while maintaining strong protections for the public.

Sincerely,

s/ Deborah Autrey              
Deborah Autrey
Vice President of MDisBA

On Behalf of the Minnesota Disability Bar Association12

s/ Marissa Ditkowsky        
Marissa Ditkowsky
Executive Director of Crip the Law


1 U.S. Ctrs. for Disease Control and Prevention, Disability Impacts All of Us Infographic, https://www.cdc.gov/disability-and-health/articles-documents/disability-impacts-all-of-us-infographic.html (last updated July 15, 2024).

2 Marissa Ditkowsky, NDLPA First-of-its-kind Data Analysis Reveals Only 5 Percent of Lawyers Identify as Disabled (Feb. 25,2025), https://cripthelaw.org/data-reveal-only-5-percent-of-lawyers-identify-as-disabled/.

3 NAT’L ASS’N OF LAW PLACEMENT, 2025 REPORT ON DIVERSITY IN U.S. LAW FIRMS 11, 16, 54 (Mar. 2026), available at https://www.nalp.org/uploads/2025NALPReportonDiversity.pdf.

4 See id. at 16.

5 Haley Moss, Raising the Bar on Accessibility: How the Bar Admissions Process Limits Disabled Law School Graduates, 28:4 AM. U. J. GENDER, SOC. POL’Y, & L. 538, 567 (2020).

6 NAT’L DISABILITY INST., NANETTE GOODMAN, MICHAEL MORRIS, & KELVIN BOSTON, FINANCIAL INEQUALITY: DISABILITY, RACE AND POVERTY IN AMERICA 12 (2019), available at https://www.nationaldisabilityinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/disability-race-poverty-in-america.pdf.

7 AM. BAR ASS’N, 2026-2027 STANDARDS AND RULES OF PROCEDURE FOR APPROVAL OF LAW SCHOOLS 303(a)(3).

8 DEBORAH JONES MERRITT & LOGAN CORNETT, BUILDING A BETTER BAR: THE TWELVE BUILDING BLOCKS OF MINIMUM COMPETENCE (Dec. 2020), available at https://iaals.du.edu/sites/default/files/documents/publications/building_a_better_bar.pdf.

9 NANETTE GOODMAN, MICHAEL MORRIS, ZACHARY MORRIS, & STEPHANIE MCGARITY, NAT’L DISABILITY INST., THE EXTRA COSTS OF LIVING WITH A DISABILITY IN THE U.S. — RESETTING THE POLICY TABLE 1, 7, 10 (Oct. 2020), available at https://www.nationaldisabilityinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/extra-costs-living-with-disability-brief.pdf.

9 AM. BAR ASS’N, SUMMARY BAR ADMISSION DATA: RACE, ETHNICITY, AND GENDER (n.d.), https://www.americanbar.org/content/dam/aba/administrative/legal_education_and_admissions_to_t he_bar/statistics/2026/2026-summary-race-ethnicity-gender.pdf (breaking down the results of the 2025 and 2026 bar admission questionnaire); Scott Devito, The Kids AreDefinitely Not All Right: An Empirical Study Establishing a Statistically Significant Negative Relationship between Receiving Accommodations in Law School and Passing the Bar Exam, 102 OR. L. REV. 1 (2023).

10 AM. BAR ASS’N, THE PLIGHT AND PROMISE OF TODAY’S FIRST-GEN LAW STUDENTS (Mar. 2026), available at https://www.americanbar.org/groups/crsj/resources/human-rights/2025-march/plight-promise-todays-first-gen-law-students/.

11 See ACCESSLEX INST., ANALYZING FIRST-TIME BAR EXAM PASSAGE ON THE UBE IN NEW YORK STATE (May 2021), available at https://www.accesslex.org/NYBOLE (compiling data that shows that success on the bar exam is tied to a student’s resources).

12 Eleanor Frisch, President of the Minnesota Disability Bar Association, abstained from the vote to submit these comments due to their role as a member of the Alternative Pathways Committee.

Post navigation

Crip the Law Demands Diploma Privilege for Accommodated July 2026 Washington State Bar Examinees  

Sidebar

Footer


Visit us on Facebook Visit us on X Visit us on LinkedIn Visit us on Instagram

Copyright © 2026. All rights reserved. Crip the Law. Privacy Policy Accessibility Statement Sitemap